#811Global
Broken Shaker
Miami, USA · Tropical garden cocktail bar · North America
A garden-backed hotel bar serving cocktails built with house elixirs, herbs, spices and fresh produce.
Description source · Checked 2026-09-09
Plan Your Visit
2727 Indian Creek Dr #11, Miami Beach, FL 33140Miami Beach
- Style
- Tropical garden cocktail barChecked 2026-09-09 · Source
- Hours
- Monday–Wednesday closed; Thursday 17:00–00:00; Friday–Saturday 17:00–01:00; Sunday 17:00–23:00.Checked 2026-09-30 · Source
- Booking
- Owner reservation page: https://freehandhotels.com/miami/broken-shaker/.Checked 2026-09-30 · Source
- Prices
- All listed signature, classic-riff and agave cocktails are US$15; Frozen Piña Colada and Basil Baby Swizzle mocktail are US$12. A 22% gratuity is added.Checked 2026-09-09 · Source
- Menu
- View the venue’s menu ↗Checked 2026-09-30 · Source
Hours and menus can change. Check the venue’s latest details before visiting.
The score & its evidence
Seven signals. One score.
26.2 / 100
The composite combines the seven weighted signals and the published adjustments. The chart shows each signal before weighting.
Read the full calculation- Guest ratings
- 75.2
- World's 50 Best
- —None found · Checked; no qualifying signal found; contributes zero
- Top 500 Bars
- —None found · Checked; no qualifying signal found; contributes zero
- Spirited Awards
- —None found · Checked; no qualifying signal found; contributes zero
- Regional Recognition
- 26.9
- Serious press
- —None found · Checked; no qualifying signal found; contributes zero
- Social Vibes
- 60.2
Weights: Guest ratings 23% · World's 50 Best 12% · Top 500 Bars 10% · Spirited 12% · Regional Recognition 18% · Press 10% · Social Vibes 15%
Missing evidence, confirmed none and evidence outside a scoring window each contribute zero. We do not redistribute their fixed weight to other signals.
Social Vibes
Score read updated:
Sentiment score
86/ 100
The historical 86/100 score, confidence and recorded mentions are unchanged. This source review does not reassess the score or establish a representative current customer sample.
Score context
Two critic reviews praise Broken Shaker’s Miami courtyard atmosphere, cocktails and hospitality. Esquire’s review is from September 2022; Condé Nast Traveler’s page does not display a publication date. These are editorial visits and operator comments, rather than a current customer sample.
Guest sources checked:
Guest score details
Source observations
- Critics praise courtyard atmosphere and cocktails
- Historical critic praise for hospitality
Source excerpt
“Ten years after opening as the locals-only hang in a tourist-slammed district, Broken Shaker remains the best bar in town.”
The quotation is from Esquire critic Madison Vain, published 29 September 2022; it is historical editorial praise.
Source: esquire.com (linked below)
This read cites editorial or award context. Those links are distinct from guest accounts; only the reviewed links in Reviews & press count toward Press.
Editorial citations in this read
- cntraveler.comcritic review plus operator quotation · Page undated; stored 1 August 2019 not verified
critic review plus operator quotation. Page undated; stored 1 August 2019 not verified. This source role does not establish a representative current guest sample.
- esquire.comcritic editorial review · 29 September 2022 8AM EDT
critic editorial review. 29 September 2022 8AM EDT. This source role does not establish a representative current guest sample.
Crowd signal
Google 4.5★ across 2,462 reviews.
View on Google · Checked . Ratings and review counts can change.
Awards
Results from the three global systems scored separately in our formula.
No recorded global awards in the scored window.
Regional Recognition
Regional and national lists, local awards and bartender peer picks considered for this room's Regional Recognition score. The strongest result from each program and year scores; assessed guides use the latest accepted dated status once.
North America's 50 Best Bars
Reviews & press
No linked coverage yet.